Written by Rita Tabar, Second Year Law Student
Cancel culture: we’ve all heard about it, or perhaps even participated in it. But what is it really? More importantly, when does public criticism become an issue interfering with basic human rights, and when does public criticism go beyond accountability? Cancel culture refers to the practice of publicly criticising individuals, companies or organisations for actions or words considered offensive, harmful or unacceptable. This often results in people withdrawing their support. With the growth of social media, it has become increasingly difficult for public figures to keep their actions and opinions out of the public eye. A single controversial comment or action is able to spread across the internet within minutes, potentially causing significant reputational and professional consequences. Typically, it begins with a public figure, influencer, celebrity, athlete or politician, making a controversial statement or engaging in questionable behaviour. The public, mainly the media, responds, demanding accountability and expressing disapproval. Eventually, this can result in lost followers, terminated brand partnerships and widespread reputational damage. But is this accountability, or have we given ourselves too much power to ruin someone’s reputation?
The arguments for and against
Cancel culture is undoubtedly controversial. Supporters argue that it promotes accountability, gives people a voice and encourages social change. It lets the public challenge powerful individuals and organisations, especially when their behaviour involves discrimination, racism or sexism. It also provides a platform for people whose concerns might otherwise have been dismissed. However, the arguments against cancel culture are equally important. Freedom of expression may be discouraged when individuals fear professional or social consequences for expressing unpopular opinions. Consequences can also be disproportionate, with someone’s reputation or career suffering because of a single mistake. Furthermore, information can be taken out of context, and the speed of social media can leave little room for explanation, reflection or forgiveness. Personally, I believe accountability is necessary, but there has to be a distinction between holding someone responsible for genuinely harmful behaviour and unfairly punishing someone for an opinion or mistake. This brings me to a more concerning question: can cancel culture become a threat to our human rights?
When does cancel culture become a human rights issue?
From a legal perspective, cancel culture becomes particularly interesting when public criticism begins to interfere with fundamental rights and freedoms. Two provisions of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR) are especially important. Article 10 protects freedom of expression, including the freedom to hold opinions and to receive and communicate information and ideas. Importantly, this protection extends to opinions that may be controversial, unpopular or unpopular within the majority. Consider an influencer expressing a controversial political opinion. They subsequently face more online criticism, lose brand partnerships and experience pressure to remove their content.
Although people have the right to disagree, situations like this can create what is known as a chilling effect. This occurs when individuals become reluctant to exercise their rights because they fear the consequences. I find this concerning because a society in which people are afraid to express lawful opinions risks discouraging open debate. There is, of course, a difference between expressing an unpopular opinion and promoting genuinely harmful conduct. However, disagreement alone should not automatically mean someone deserves to be silenced. Article 8 of the ECHR, which protects the right to respect for private and family life, is another important consideration. Cancel culture can extend far beyond criticising someone’s public statements or actions. Personal information may be exposed online, private conversations or photographs circulated without consent, and family members targeted as a result of someone else’s controversy. This raises serious concerns about privacy, dignity and personal security. While public figures may face greater scrutiny, their right to privacy is more so affected because they have an online platform.
Who has actually been cancelled?
We’ve seen these controversies play out repeatedly. Ellen DeGeneres faced significant public backlash following allegations from former employees about a toxic workplace environment. Her show ended in 2022. J.K. Rowling, author of the Harry Potter series, has faced considerable criticism and boycotts following her public comments about transgender rights and gender identity. While some have strongly criticised her views, others defend her right to express them. Her situation demonstrates how complicated the relationship between public disagreement and freedom of expression can become. Social media influencer James Charles also faced substantial backlash following allegations of inappropriate communications with underage boys. These controversies demonstrate that cancel culture can involve much more than unpopular opinions; it can also concern serious questions of conduct and accountability.
So, where do we draw the line?
Cancel culture is not inherently good or bad. It does give people a voice, challenge those in positions of power and encourage accountability. But, equally, it can create an environment where public judgement becomes disproportionate, privacy is disregarded and individuals become afraid to express themselves. Ultimately, I believe we must differentiate between holding someone accountable and taking away their opportunity to learn, explain themselves and grow. Having a public platform should not mean surrendering fundamental rights, just as freedom of expression should not mean freedom from accountability. Possibly the real question isn’t whether
someone deserves to be cancelled, but whether we’ve become too comfortable deciding that they
do.


Leave a Reply